Mercedes-BMW rivalry continues even fiercer within the electrical period. We attempt to reply which producer provides a greater and extra full electrical mannequin vary.
The electrical period started for each producers with a mannequin which is now not in manufacturing at present.BMW launched the revolutionary and progressive BMW i3 in 2013, which had a novel physique construction with a carbon-fiber-reinforced plastic (CFRP) security cell grafted onto an aluminum construction supporting the axles, powertrain, and battery. BMW offered greater than 250,000 items and was in manufacturing from September 2013 to the summer season of 2023.
Mercedes was not as profitable with its first large-series electrical mannequin. The electrical Mercedes B-Class was offered from November 2014 to October 2017 and was based mostly on the second-generation B-Class W246.
Devoted electrical platform for Mercedes, standard plaform (with one exception) for BMW. Does it matter?The 2 producers have chosen completely different paths to develop their electrical mannequin vary. Mercedes constructed a devoted electrical platform to develop the posh vary, consisting of 4 fashions – EQE, EQS, EQE SUV, and EQS SUV.
BMW selected the answer of utilizing the standard CLAR platform for the posh electrical fashions with a purpose to scale back prices and have flexibility in manufacturing, with diesel, petrol, PHEV, and electrical variations being produced on the identical manufacturing line. Solely the BMW iX is an exception, utilizing a hybrid platform that takes solely the entrance and rear axles from the X5.
Mercedes BMW
Compact class SUV EQA iX1
EQB –
-iX2
Center class SUV EQC iX3
Large class SUV EQE SUV iX
Luxurious class SUV EQS SUV –
Maybach EQS SUV
Center class sedan – i4
Large class sedan EQE i5
Luxurious classEQS i7
Though each producers have developed luxurious electrical fashions, neither has an 800V electrical platform however solely a 400V one, The utmost charging velocity is 200 kW in comparison with 350 kW in some Hyundai/Kia fashions and Porsche.
Each producers use standard platforms for the iX1/iX2 and EQA/EQB within the compact vary, however nobody has a compact electrical mannequin. Mercedes has introduced that it’s going to undoubtedly drop the A-Class, together with the standard variations, and there are solely rumors a couple of doable BMW i1.
What does the longer term seem like?Mercedes’ luxurious vary consisting of the EQE, EQS, EQE SUV, and EQS SUV is promoting poorly within the U.S. and China, and the Stuttgart producer is on the lookout for methods to enhance. Weaker rear entry criticized by the Chinese language due to the aerodynamic form, decrease high quality supplies than within the S-Class/E-Class, and excessive costs are the principle criticisms.
Within the compact vary, Mercedes is getting ready a revolution with the brand new MMA platform, developed as Electrical First. It can debut in 2024 on the brand new Mercedes CLA and can then be used on the longer term CLA Taking pictures brake, GLA/EQA, and GLB/EQB.
In 2025, the brand new Mercedes G-Class electrical can have the world premiere, with as much as 4 motors and optionally with a solid-state battery.
BMW is creating a devoted electrical platform for the Neue Klasse mannequin vary. Bavarians will launch six fashions in 24 months, beginning with the iX3 successor in 2025. An electrical equal for the three Sequence and probably a compact electrical equal of the 1 Sequence will comply with.
Compact class SUV: Mercedes EQA/EQB vs BMW iX1/iX2
The Mercedes EQA and EQB have undergone a discreet facelift, and the 250+ variations have acquired a barely bigger battery. The Mercedes EQA and EQB have a couple of extra miles of vary than the BMW iX1 however have decrease charging speeds (100 in comparison with 130 kW) and are costlier.
Mercedes EQA Mercedes EQB BMW iX1 BMW iX2
EQA 250ix1 eDrive20
Max. Output (PS)190204
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/66.566.5/64.7
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)14.415.4
Vary (km)525474
Charging velocity DC (kW)100130
Value (euro, checklist worth)50,77753,31447,900
EQA 250+EQB 250+
Max. Output (PS)190190
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/70.5 -/70.5
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)14.415.3
Vary (km)560533
Charging velocity DC (kW)100100
Value (euro, checklist worth)52,20553,314
EQA 300 4MaticEQB 300 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)228228
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/66.5 -/66.5
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)16.717.3
Vary (km)457445
Charging velocity DC (kW)100100
Value (euro, checklist worth)53,52055,519
EQA 350 4MaticEQB 350 4Matic iX1 xDrive30ix2 xDrive30
Max. Output (PS)292292313313
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/66.5 -/66.566.5/64.7 66.5/64.7
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)16.717.316.916.3
Vary (km)457445439449
Charging velocity DC (kW)100100130130
Value (euro, checklist worth)56,42458,19755,00056,500
Center class SUV: Mercedes EQC vs BMW iX3
The Mercedes EQC and BMW iX3 are the oldest electrical fashions in manufacturing of the 2 producers.
The Mercedes EQC carries over the entrance and rear axles from the previous GLC era however has no air suspension choice. The suspension is delicate, the steering is oblique, and the agility is poor. Mercedes just lately stopped manufacturing of the EQC as a result of very low demand.
The BMW iX3 is produced in China and has a single rear axle model.
Mercedes is eyeing a brand new EQC based mostly on the brand new MMA platform, whereas the iX3’s successor will likely be BMW’s first mannequin on the brand new devoted electrical Neue Klasse platform.
BMiX3
iX3
Max. Output (PS)286
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh )80/74
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)18.5
Vary (km)461
Charging velocity DC (kW)150
Value (euro, checklist worth)67,300
Large class SUV: Mercedes EQE SUV vs BMW iX
The Mercedes EQE SUV provides six variations in comparison with solely three on the BMW iX as a result of Mercedes additionally provides two rear-wheel drive variations, whereas all BMW iX variations come normal with two engines and electrical all-wheel drive.
The Mercedes EQE SUV options just one battery kind, whereas the BMW iX provides a smaller battery within the base model and a bigger one within the different two variations. BMW provides sooner charging velocity and an extended vary, aside from the bottom model. There are big variations in pricing, because the cheaper BMW iX is less expensive than the equal EQE SUV model due to the smaller battery. The iX xDrive50 can also be less expensive than the AMG EQE 43 4Matic regardless of having the next battery capability and longer vary.
Mercedes EQE SUV BMW iX
EQE 300
Max. Output (PS)245
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)18.3
Vary (km)573
Charging velocity DC (kW)170
Value (euro, checklist worth)83,478
EQE 350+
Max. Output (PS)292
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)18.2
Vary (km)614
Charging velocity DC (kW)170
Value (euro, checklist worth)86,810
EQE 350 4Matic iX xDrive40
Max. Output (PS)292326
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.676,6/71
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)18.819.4
Vary (km)553424
Charging velocity DC (kW)170150
Value (euro, checklist worth)89,54777,300
EQE 500 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)408
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)18.8
Vary (km)594
Charging velocity DC (kW)170
Value (euro, checklist worth)99,841
AMG EQE 43 4MaticiX xDrive50
Max. Output (PS)476523
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6111.5/105.2
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)23.219.9
Vary (km)469629
Charging velocity DC (kW)170195
Value (euro, checklist worth)124,920107,900
AMG EQE 53 4Matic+iX M60
Max. Output (PS)625619
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6111.5/105.2
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)23.221.8
Vary (km)451564
Charging velocity DC (kW)170195
Value (euro, checklist worth)139,438143,100
Luxurious Class SUV: Mercedes EQS SUV and Mercedes-Maybach EQS 680 SUV has no rival at BMW
BMW has no rival for the EQS SUV, not having a much bigger SUV than the iX. The Mercedes EQS SUV is the electrical equal of the GLS and includes a 7-seat configuration. Mercedes has put one of the best know-how into the EQS SUV: integral steering with as much as 10 levels steering angle, adaptive air suspension, Hyperscreen, and a really giant battery with a web capability of 107.8 kWh. But it surely solely prices as much as a most of 200 kW.
Mercedes EQS SUV
EQS 450+
Max. Output (PS)360
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/107.8
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)19.1
Vary (km)709
Charging velocity DC (kW)200
Value (euro, checklist worth)110,801
EQS 450 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)360
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/107.8
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)20.6
Vary (km)658
Charging velocity DC (kW)200
Value (euro, checklist worth)114,609
EQS 500 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)449
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/107.8
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)20.6
Vary (km)658
Charging velocity DC (kW)200
Value (euro, checklist worth)124,545
EQS 580 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)544
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/107.8
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)20.6
Vary (km)656
Charging velocity DC (kW)200
Value (euro, checklist worth)147,922
Maybach EQS 680 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)658
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh )na
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)22.5
Vary (km)600
Charging velocity DC (kW)200
Value (euro, checklist worth)na
Center class sedans: BMW i4 has no rival at Mercedes
The BMW i4 is constructed on the 4 Sequence platform and is a four-door electrical coupe that has no rival from Mercedes as a result of Mercedes doesn’t but have an electrical C-Class. Mercedes is contemplating an electrical C-Class based mostly on the upcoming MMA platform.
Though constructed on a standard platform, the BMW i4 is one in every of BMW’s finest electrical fashions. It provides excellent efficiency, is attractively priced, and the i4 M50 model is less expensive than the M4.It’s accessible in three variations, two of that are rear-wheel drive.
BMW i4
i4 edrive35 Gran Coupe
Max. Output (PS)286
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh )70.2/67
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)15.8
Vary (km)482
Charging velocity DC (kW)180
Value (euro, checklist worth)56,500
i4 eDrive40 Gran Coupe
Max. Output (PS)340
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh )83.9/80.7
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)16.1
Vary (km)589
Charging velocity DC (kW)205
Value (euro, checklist worth)59,800
i4 M50 Gran Coupe
Max. Output (PS)544
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh )83.9/80.7
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)18.1
Vary (km)519
Charging velocity DC (kW)205
Value (euro, checklist worth)71,000
Large class sedans: Mercedes EQE vs BMW i5
The Mercedes EQE was launched in 2022 and has a full vary of six variations. Two rear-wheel drive and 4 all-wheel-drive variations can be found, two of that are AMG. The BMW i5 solely debuted two months in the past and is accessible in two variations for now. The BMW i5 is cheaper than the Mercedes EQE and has the next charging velocity of 205 kW in comparison with 170 kW, because the i5 has a smaller battery. Nevertheless, the BMW i5 and Mercedes EQE have comparable ranges.
Mercedes EQE BMW i5
EQE 300
Max. Output (PS)245
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)16.8
Vary (km)615
Charging velocity DC (kW)170
Value (euro, checklist worth)67,187
EQE 350+i5 eDrive40
Max. Output (PS)292340
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6 -/81.2
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)16.816
Vary (km)615579
Charging velocity DC (kW)170205
Value (euro, checklist worth)70,99570,200
EQE 350 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)292
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)17
Vary (km)616
Charging velocity DC (kW)170
Value (euro, checklist worth)74,149
EQE 500 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)408
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)17.1
Vary (km)613
Charging velocity DC (kW)170
Value (euro, checklist worth)88,215
AMG EQE 43 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)476
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)20.6
Vary (km)503
Charging velocity DC (kW)170
Value (euro, checklist worth)104,756
AMG EQE 53 4Matic+i5 M60 xDrive
Max. Output (PS)625601
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/90.6 -/81.2
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)20.418.2
Vary (km)502515
Charging velocity DC (kW)170205
Value (euro, checklist worth)110,70699,500
Luxurious class sedans: Mercedes EQS vs BMW i7
The Mercedes EQS is accessible in 5 variations, one in every of which is rear-wheel drive and one is AMG, whereas the i7 may be configured in three variations, with the top-of-the-line i7 M70 xDrive model just lately launched. Each fashions have one of the best applied sciences accessible: adaptive air suspension, lively anti-roll bars (normal or non-compulsory, relying on model) and integral steering.
The Mercedes EQS advantages from the benefit of a devoted electrical platform and higher aerodynamics. With a barely bigger battery capability, the Mercedes EQS has an extended vary than the i7. With a variety of 748 km WLTP, the Mercedes EQS 450+ has one of many longest ranges in the marketplace.
Surprisingly, the Mercedes EQS drives extra agile and lean much less in corners than the i7, however the i7 is extra snug and has a greater high quality inside than the Mercedes EQS.
Mercedes EQS BMW i7
EQS 450+i7 eDrive50
Max. Output (PS)360455
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/108.4105.7/101.7
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)16.619.1
Vary (km)748611
Charging velocity DC (kW)200195
Value (euro, checklist worth)109,551115,700
EQS 450 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)360
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/108.4
Power comsumption (kWh/100 km)17.4
Vary (km)712
Charging velocity DC (kW)200
Value (euro, checklist worth)113,359
EQS 500 4Matic
Max. Output (PS)449
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/108.4
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)17.4
Vary (km)711
Charging velocity DC (kW)200
Value (euro, checklist worth)125,378
EQS 580 4Matici7 xDrive60
Max. Output (PS)544544
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/108.4105.7/101.7
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)17.518.4
Vary (km)709624
Charging velocity DC (kW)200195
Value (euro, checklist worth)141,705139,900
AMG EQS 53 4Matici7 M70 xDrive
Max. Output (PS)658659
Battery capability brutto/web (kWh ) -/108.4105.7/101.7
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)21.420.8
Vary (km)569559
Charging velocity DC (kW)200195
Value (euro, checklist worth)155,009181,800