German auto motor und sport journal has in contrast the Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic and the BMW i7 xDrive60 and solutions who builds the world’s greatest luxurious electrical limousine.
Picture: Auto motor und sport
The Mercedes EQS and BMW i7 compete in the identical phase however have totally different philosophies. The BMW i7 is produced on the identical platform as the traditional and Plug-In variations of the 7 Collection on the identical manufacturing line at BMW’s Dingolfing plant. BMW’s philosophy to any extent further is to launch the electrical model first, adopted by the opposite variations. Within the case of the 7 Collection, a diesel and a Plug-In will comply with for Europe, whereas a petroleum model might be obtainable solely within the US. In distinction, the Mercedes EQS fully differs from the S-Class and is constructed on the devoted EVA II electrical platform.
BMW i7 xDrive60: supreme consolation, higher high quality, however decrease agility, excessive consumption
The brand new BMW 7 Collection is an enormous automotive being 13 cm/5.11 in longer than the previous prolonged wheelbase model, 5 cm/1.97 in taller, and roughly the identical width. The rise in peak is because of an 11 cm/4.33 in Li-Ion battery with a capability of 101.7 kWh being mounted on the ground. The rise in size is defined extra by BMW’s want to place the 7 Collection even increased than by the necessity for further area. Within the entrance, passengers sit in nice, extra-wide seats electrically adjustable in a number of instructions, ventilated, and heated seats, whereas glorious high quality supplies and unbeatable ergonomics characterize the inside regardless of the multitude of features.
The Interplay Bar, illuminated from the rear in several shades, spans your entire inside width. It may be used to regulate air distribution, open the glovebox or shut the automated doorways.The BMW i7 xDrive60 is powered by two current-excited synchronous motors quite than everlasting magnets, so BMW doesn’t use uncommon earth in its motors. A 190 kW motor works on the entrance and a 230 kW motor on the rear, producing 400 kW and 745 Nm (549 lb-ft).
In comparison with the i4 M50, the acceleration doesn’t appear so violent because of the further weight. Nonetheless, in the event you take a look at the acceleration figures, you notice that the unimaginable pressure of the 2 motors has been solely barely mitigated. As for refinement, the 2 electrical motors make us neglect concerning the well-known V12 and produce solely a slight hum.
The restoration system, whose automated technique considers not solely the automobile in entrance and the topography of the highway but in addition the site visitors lights, works effectively and, along with the 0.24 Cx, contributes to effectivity.
The check mannequin had the absolute best drivetrain: commonplace adaptive air suspension plus lively anti-roll bars (3,700 euro/$4,039 ). These scale back cornering roll however typically not sufficient. On straight traces, the system decouples the stabilizer bars, enhancing consolation. The air suspension affords a excessive diploma of consolation, and solely on deeper potholes with sharp edges does it make a slight noise with out disturbing passengers.Whereas consolation achieves perfection, conventional BMW sportiness is missing even with the onboard M Sport bundle (6,900 euro/$7,531), which is extra a design bundle than a technical one. The integral steering with its 3.5-degree steering angle doesn’t do a lot for agility, nevertheless it contributes to higher dealing with in tight areas. With a 49/51% entrance/rear weight distribution, the BMW i7 understeers on corners, however the electronics discreetly mitigate the phenomenon.
With a weight distribution of 49:51% entrance to rear, typically i7 pushes into understeer in corners, however the management techniques intervene discreetly to decrease it.The BMW i7 is, subsequently, a powerful automotive for lengthy journeys, however the excessive vitality consumption within the check of 35 kWh/100 km requires charging breaks each 320 km (199 miles). Then again, the i7 charged rapidly at high-power DC stations. In 18 minutes, BMW charged 51 kW or 50% of the battery. The typical charging energy was 147 kW, and it took 70 minutes for a full cost.
Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic: Extra agile and spacious, higher rangeBuilt on a devoted platform, the Mercedes EQS stands out with an distinctive Cx of 0.20 and a cab-forward physique design. As well as, the Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic options two everlasting magnet synchronous motors of 135 kW on the entrance and 255 kW on the rear producing 385 kW (400 kW shortly) and 858 Nm (633 lb-ft), with torque distribution checked 10,000 occasions per minute by the digital management system.
Two different notable options of the EQS are the pressurized cooling of the electrical motor rotor inside with a water lance and the ribs within the underbody panels that defend the battery casing beneath from potential knocks. By the way in which, Mercedes guarantees a extra prolonged battery guarantee than different producers of 10 years or 250,000 km/155,342 miles as an alternative of 8 years or 160,000 km/99,419 miles.
By design, the Mercedes EQS appears smaller than the i7, nevertheless it’s not. The multi-contour (1,737 euro/$1,896) and multi-way adjustable entrance seats are snug however supply good help. The driving place is 4.5 cm decrease than within the i7, and the seats are nicely built-in however not as massive as within the i7, being separated by the tall middle console.
Within the rear, the Mercedes EQS affords an additional 4 cm on the knees, and regardless of the arched roof, it additionally offers a one-finger taller inside peak. The boot can be extra important than the 7 Collection, however the payload is way decrease than the BMW at 453 kg/999 kilos in comparison with 571 kg/1,259 kilos within the BMW.
Just like the BMW, the Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic’s navigation system considers charging stops when wanted by counting the time required to cease in line with the charging velocity.
Mercedes additionally accelerates vehemently, easily, harmoniously, and quietly. You get the sensation that the Mercedes is quicker, however the distinction in acceleration is simply 0.4 seconds within the Mercedes’ favor, whereas in-gear accelerations are an identical.
The Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic comes commonplace with adaptive air suspension and non-compulsory all-wheel steering with a 10-degree steering angle (1,547 euro/$1,690, may also be ordered over-the-air; the usual is a 4.5-degree steering angle). The ten-degree steering angle makes the EQS extra maneuverable in tight areas, with a steering diameter corresponding to a compact automotive. The steering can be very responsive and smoother, and the automotive doesn’t understeer when cornering. It solely provides up its calm neutrality in Sport mode, with a little bit of back-swing beneath extra exhilarating acceleration. In any other case, it affords excellent grip and has distinctive dynamics confirmed in dynamic checks.
The Mercedes brakes extra brutally and has barely shorter braking distances, however the brake pedal isn’t linear, and it’s arduous to manage, particularly within the first section, in auto restoration mode. In distinction, BMW affords a extra controllable and linear brake pedal.
The EQS is barely extra agile however much less snug than the i7. On arduous and quick bumps, the EQS responds a little bit extra harshly. Then again, it retains physique actions extra firmly beneath management.
In distinction, the Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic has a extra prolonged vary of 359 km/223 miles as an alternative of 320 km/199 miles (478 km/297 miles in contrast with 427 km/265 miles in eco mode), because of a barely bigger battery and decrease gas consumption of 33.4 kWh/100 km within the check. However even with a much bigger battery, it expenses sooner. For instance, in 18 minutes, it charged 50% of the battery (54 kWh in comparison with 51 within the BMW), and a full cost took 61 minutes in comparison with 70 within the BMW.
Conclusion
The Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic wins over the BMW i7 xDrive60 as a result of it’s extra economical, has a extra prolonged vary, expenses sooner, is extra agile, and brakes higher. As well as, though it doesn’t look, it has a roomier inside and boot. However the BMW is extra snug and affords higher inside supplies and a extra linear brake pedal. It was, nonetheless, not sufficient for victory. Mercees EQS 580 4Matic received with 659 factors aginat 635 factors for BMW.
ModelBMW i7 xDrive60Mercedes EQS 580 4Matic+
Engine2, electric2, electrical
Max. output (HP)544523
Max. torque (Nm)745858
TransmissionAWDAWD
Gearboxautomatic, 1 gearautomatic, 1 gear
L/w/h (mm)5,391/1,950/1,5445,216/1,926/1,512
Wheelbase mm)3,2153,210
Boot quantity (l)500610-1,770
Accelerations (s)
0-50 km/h2.11.8
0-100 km/h4.64.2
0-120 km/h65.7
0-140 km/h7.77.4
0-160 km/h 9.89.6
0-180 km/h 12.612.4
0-200 km/h 18.116
Sprints (s)
60-100 km/h 2.12
80-120 km/h 2.62.5
Slalom 18 m km/h)65.467.1
Double lane change (km/h)133.8139.4
Prime velocity (km/h)240210
Brakes
from 100 km/h (m)35.734.1
Noise degree
at 80 km/h (dBA)5960
at 100 km/h (dBA)6263
at 130 km/h (dBA)6465
at 160 km/h (dBA)6868
Power consumption (kWh/100 km)
Eco drive 26.225.1
Sport drive 39.735.2
Common 35,033.4
Value (euro with VAT) GERMANY139,900141,705.20
Value (USD) US 119,900125,950